CALL US: (925) 660-7544

Enforcing a No Contest Clause in California

A will or trust typically contains a no contest clause, which is a provision that penalizes a beneficiary if he “contests” the will or trust. We have extensiveexperience drafting effective no contest clauses and litigating issuespertaining to the applicability of a no contest clause.

On January 1, 2010, new statutes governing the enforcement of no contest clauses became operative, with respect to truststhat became irrevocable on or after January 1, 2001. Prob. Code, § §21310-21315.


The applicability of the new statutes is significant because the standard to bring a direct contest, without triggering the enforcement of a no contest clause, has changed from “reasonable cause” to
“probable cause.”

Under the former standard, Probate Code section 21306(a), a no contest clause was enforceable against a contest brought without “reasonable cause.” Reasonable cause is defined as follows:
“the party filing…the contest has possession of facts that would cause a reasonable person to believe that the allegations and other factual contentions in the matter filed with the court may be proven…or are likely to be proven after a reasonable opportunity for further investigation or discovery.”

Under the new standard, Probate Code section 21311(a)(1), a no contest clause is enforceable against a direct contest that is brought without “probable cause.” Probable cause is defined as whether “if, at the time of filing a contest, the facts known to the contestant would cause a reasonable person to believe there is a reasonable likelihood the requested relief will be granted after an opportunity for
further investigation or discovery.”

Although the Legislature intended to simplify the law pertaining to no contest clauses, we anticipate the new “probable cause” standard will be the subject of future litigation.

Loren Barr
by Loren Barr
Updated: January 11, 2024

Related Stories

California Prudent Investor Rule for Trustees in Litigation
The California Prudent Investor Rule is a critical legal standard that governs the conduct of trustees in managing trust assets. This rule, which is...
Read More img img
Will vs. Trust in California: What to Choose in 2022
How do you compare a living trust vs. a will in California? Wills and trusts both allow you to dispose of your property to beneficiaries. Beyond...
Read More img img
Online Estate Planning Programs
For many young parents this scenario is familiar: You and your spouse are flying across the country for some family event-a wedding, the death of a...
Read More img img